Comments on: Extremist Shiv Sena targets Shahrukh Khan http://www.pakistanihousewife.com/extremist-shiv-sena-targets-shahrukh-khan/ Its 'Her' Perspective of the World Fri, 30 Jul 2010 11:07:17 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=abc By: Siddharth http://www.pakistanihousewife.com/extremist-shiv-sena-targets-shahrukh-khan/comment-page-1/#comment-2003 Siddharth Thu, 25 Mar 2010 10:54:41 +0000 http://www.pakistanihousewife.com/?p=2402#comment-2003 You said: "In democratic and secular India a muslim does not even have the freedom to express his opinion in mere words!" 1. This is a Straw-Man fallacy of logic. You have taken one incident and generalised it to the entire country, and added "democratic and secular " as though it's a means of discrediting the two. 2. In this very same country, even a Hindu can say something that may piss off the Shiv Sena. Those people have held the city to ransom even for comments made by people who belive in the Hindutva philosophy too. The Shiv Sena are rabid and don't care about what anyone thinks, be it Hindu, Muslim or otherwise. So your rhetorical statement lacks merit. You said: “In democratic and secular India a muslim does not even have the freedom to express his opinion in mere words!”

1. This is a Straw-Man fallacy of logic. You have taken one incident and generalised it to the entire country, and added “democratic and secular ” as though it’s a means of discrediting the two.

2. In this very same country, even a Hindu can say something that may piss off the Shiv Sena. Those people have held the city to ransom even for comments made by people who belive in the Hindutva philosophy too. The Shiv Sena are rabid and don’t care about what anyone thinks, be it Hindu, Muslim or otherwise.

So your rhetorical statement lacks merit.

]]> By: Stinger http://www.pakistanihousewife.com/extremist-shiv-sena-targets-shahrukh-khan/comment-page-1/#comment-1934 Stinger Thu, 25 Feb 2010 02:52:00 +0000 http://www.pakistanihousewife.com/?p=2402#comment-1934 ^ To Murtaza, maybe you didn't notice but most of the this entry was a excerpt from Shiv Sina's own spokesmen. You're attacking the messenger rather then dealing with the message. The media only talks about Muslim extremists as though no other extremist exists in the world, this article proves that wrong. ^ To Murtaza, maybe you didn’t notice but most of the this entry was a excerpt from Shiv Sina’s own spokesmen. You’re attacking the messenger rather then dealing with the message. The media only talks about Muslim extremists as though no other extremist exists in the world, this article proves that wrong.

]]> By: murtaza http://www.pakistanihousewife.com/extremist-shiv-sena-targets-shahrukh-khan/comment-page-1/#comment-1864 murtaza Thu, 11 Feb 2010 10:35:13 +0000 http://www.pakistanihousewife.com/?p=2402#comment-1864 people like you are no different from shiv sena hooligans. shiv sena of the india has not opposed shahrukh for his religion, but for his support to pakistani players.shiv sena is fanatic, but so are you in spewing poison by spreading communalism and hatred. read the newspaper well before you think of blogging next time..... people like you are no different from shiv sena hooligans.

shiv sena of the india has not opposed shahrukh for his religion, but for his support to pakistani players.shiv sena is fanatic, but so are you in spewing poison by spreading communalism and hatred.

read the newspaper well before you think of blogging next time…..

]]>